Українська
English
Introduction: why compare aid formats today
During a prolonged war, the issue of aid effectiveness goes beyond emotional support and moves into the realm of rational decisions. The choice of format - direct donations, military bonds, or earmarked funds - determines the speed of meeting needs, the sustainability of public finances, and the transparency of the result. Every hryvnia should be spent where it will have the greatest impact right now.
This article will help you understand the differences between the approaches, the risks and benefits of each tool, and when to combine them. We will compare the speed of impact, the ability to track results, financial feasibility, and appropriate scenarios. The goal is to provide you with clear guidelines for making an informed choice and maximizing your participation.
A brief overview of aid formats: direct donations, military bonds, and targeted collections
Direct donations are non-refundable contributions to the needs of the army, medics, volunteers, or trusted foundations. They provide the highest rate of transformation of funds into specific purchases: drones, thermal imagers, vehicles, turnstiles, communications. You get clear results and reporting from a trusted organization, as well as the ability to support urgent requests within days, sometimes hours.
Military bonds are a public borrowing instrument that allows you to temporarily provide funds to the defense budget against a fixed income. By purchasing bonds, you strengthen the liquidity of public finances, help to cover cash gaps and plan expenditures for a longer period of time than in the format of one-time donations. The investor receives a return of the face value and coupon income within a specified timeframe, which makes the instrument attractive to those who want to combine support for the country with financial discipline.
Targeted fundraising is a targeted model where funds are allocated for a specific task: for example, the purchase of a UAV system for a specific brigade or the rehabilitation of a medical unit. This format increases the sense of direct impact and allows for control over the stages of implementation, but usually requires more time for request verification, logistics, and coordination with the unit. As a result, the timeline can be longer than for direct donations.
Each format plays a different role in the overall support system. Donations cover the most pressing needs here and now, bonds ensure macro-financial stability and planning, and targeted fees increase the targeting and transparency of complex projects. The choice depends on your priorities: speed, predictability, or maximum specificity in the use of funds. The optimal strategy often involves a combination of these tools.
How military bonds work: mechanics, yield, taxation, liquidity
Military bonds are government debt securities, the proceeds of which are used to meet the needs of the budget during a war. You buy a bond on the primary or secondary market through banks and licensed brokers, choosing the maturity and coupon rate. The state undertakes to repay the face value on a certain date and pay interest income according to the schedule.
The mechanics are simple: choose the issue (ISIN), investment amount, and intermediary, sign the contract, and replenish your securities account. The coupon is accrued in accordance with the terms of the issue - once a month, quarterly or at the end of the term, depending on the coupon structure. Ownership is recorded by the depository system, which guarantees transparency and protection of your assets.
The yield is determined by the coupon rate and the purchase price. If you buy at par and hold to maturity, the expected return is equal to the coupon rate minus taxes and intermediary fees. If you buy below par or sell earlier on the secondary market, you may realize an additional exchange rate gain, either positive or negative, depending on market conditions. The level of interest rates is influenced by inflation expectations, the NBU’s monetary policy, and investor demand.
Taxation depends on the applicable regulations: generally, coupon income is subject to personal income tax and military duty, and taxable gains may arise from the sale on the secondary market. The exact rates and exemptions are determined by the legislation on the date of the transaction, so you should check the current rules with your broker or tax advisor. Intermediary commissions (account opening, custody, and transaction fees) also affect the net yield.
Liquidity is ensured by the possibility of early sale on the secondary market, but the price may differ from the nominal value. With increased volatility, the spreads between the buy and sell prices increase, which affects the actual income in case of an exit before maturity. If your goal is a predictable financial result and maximum budget support, it is advisable to hold the securities until maturity.
If you want to combine support for the country with financial discipline, receive a regular coupon, and contribute to budget stability, military bonds are a logical choice. They strengthen macro-financial sustainability and allow the state to plan spending, while direct donations are more effective for immediate, targeted needs. A balanced approach can include a core bond portfolio and regular donations for urgent projects.
Direct donations: speed, transparency, operational risks, and the role of foundations
Direct donations are the fastest way to turn funds into concrete assistance: from turnstiles and tactical medicine to communications, transportation, and UAVs. The key advantage is speed: the money transferred today can become purchases that meet the critical needs of the units in a few days. This is especially important at peak times, when every day counts and flexibility in decision-making is required.
Transparency is ensured by the practice of public reporting: foundations and volunteer organizations publish acts, invoices, photo and video confirmations, as well as reports on delivery to specific units. You can track the path of funds from payment to delivery to the final recipient. To increase trust, you should pay attention to audits, certificates of humanitarian activity, partnerships with units, and a history of successful cases.
The role of theUNITY INTERNATIONAL MOVEMENT is to focus on projects with quick and measurable impact. This approach combines prompt communication with requesters, clear verification of needs, and a structured supply chain. This allows us to direct donations to where the impact is greatest - to critical positions that directly affect safety and life.
Compared to other formats of support, direct donations do not provide a financial return, but they ensure maximum targeting and urgency. For many philanthropists, this is a conscious choice: giving up material benefits for the sake of quick results. At the same time, donations are the easiest way to close bottlenecks that are not always covered by public procurement.
Criteria for choosing an aid format: speed, scale, feedback, financial feasibility, tax aspects
Start by prioritizing speed. If the goal is to fill an urgent need within days, direct donations are the most effective due to the minimal decision-making chain and procurement flexibility. If the horizon is longer and planned public spending is important, military bonds strengthen fiscal sustainability, while targeted fees help implement more complex projects with a longer cycle.
The second criterion is scale and predictability. For large initiatives with phased implementation, bonds (macro-financial support) combined with earmarked funds (targeted implementation for specific tasks) are appropriate. Direct donations work better as an ambulance and to close bottlenecks where time is of the essence. The balance between instruments is determined by whether the effect is needed immediately or whether the key is continuity of funding.
The third aspect is feedback and transparency. Donations and earmarked funds provide visibility of the result through reports, invoices, photos, and feedback from the units. Bonds, on the other hand, have a systemic effect at the level of public finances, but their impact is less targeted to a specific unit. Choose the format that meets your control needs: from personalized targeting to macro-level support.
The fourth criterion is financial feasibility and risk tolerance. Military bonds combine support with yield and return of principal, but involve market and liquidity risks, as well as intermediary fees. Donations do not return financially, but provide the maximum social ROI in urgent scenarios. Targeted fees are strong where specialization and cost containment are required, but may take longer to implement.
Finally, consider tax aspects and legal details. Bond coupon income is taxable under current rules, which should be clarified before investing. For donors, check the status of the recipient, the ability to obtain supporting documents for accounting, and the requirements for international transfers if necessary. For many benefactors, a combined approach is becoming optimal: a basic portfolio of military bonds as a contribution to stability and regular donations or participation in targeted fundraising for operational and specialized tasks.
Comparing military bonds and donations: pros and cons
Direct donations for operational needs: speed, targeting, evidence
Advantages:
- The fastest path from payment to result thanks to a short decision-making chain and flexible procurement. This allows you to quickly cover the shortage of turnstiles, communications, batteries, spare parts and UAVs when every day counts.
- High targeting and the ability to support units that provide verified requests with specific technical requirements. This enhances the marginal effect of each hryvnia and reduces the risk of aid being diluted.
- Evidence and transparency through public reports, acceptance certificates, invoices, photo and video evidence of delivery to specific teams. This builds trust and allows you to track the path of funds from contribution to use.
-
Lack of financial return and coupon income. Donations are deliberately non-refundable support with a focus on social rather than monetary results.
-
Dependence on the operational capacity of the organization, its logistics, established supply channels, and work with suppliers. Weak processes increase the risk of inefficiency.
-
Delays due to force majeure, market shortages, or price hikes are possible. During peak periods, logistical bottlenecks can slow down sales even if funds are available.
Targeted fees for specific projects: milestone control, community engagement, evidence
Advantages:
- A clearly defined goal and detailed procurement specifications for a specific task (for example, a UAV system for a selected team or medical equipment with certain parameters). This strengthens quality control and compliance with the unit’s expectations.
- High evidence at every stage: from request verification and signing contracts with suppliers to acceptance, testing, and integration. Step-by-step reporting increases trust and manageability of the process.
- The ability to mobilize the community around a specific goal, increasing the communication effect and speed of fundraising. Pooled donor support allows for complex and capital-intensive solutions.
-
Longer implementation cycle due to verification, tendering, manufacturing, logistics, and installation. The total time may exceed the horizons of urgent donors.
-
Dependence on collecting the full amount to start or complete the project, which sometimes causes pauses and restarts of communications.
-
Risk of changes in the unit’s technical requirements or market availability of kits, requiring backup scenarios and flexible re-planning.
Military bonds for budget sustainability: coupon income, return of face value, macro effect
Advantages:
- Support for macro-financial stability of the state and predictability of defense spending. The borrowed funds help to cover cash gaps, plan procurement and maintain budget balance.
- The return of the face value and coupon income is scheduled, which combines civic participation with financial discipline. For investors, it is a way to support the country without losing capital in the longer term.
- Transparency of ownership through the depository system, standardized brokerage procedures and clear terms of issues, which reduces operational risks and increases investor security.
Disadvantages:
- Market and liquidity risks in case of early sale: the price may deviate from par depending on rates, demand and volatility. This is important to take into account if you may need funds earlier.
- Taxation of coupon income and intermediary commissions reduce the net yield, and the details depend on the broker’s current rules and tariffs.
- Less targeting at the level of a single unit. The effect is manifested systematically, at the level of public finances, and it is more difficult to "see" it as a specific piece of equipment.
When to choose what: typical scenarios
When the task is urgent and the countdown is on for days, direct donations work best. It’s about a shortage of turnstiles, batteries, communication equipment, or spare parts that need to be purchased immediately and delivered without unnecessary approvals. Proven foundations with well-established logistics and public reporting ensure a minimum cycle from payment to delivery, making donations the best choice for critical bottlenecks.
When the implementation horizon is one to three months, a combination of targeted fees and targeted donations is advisable. Projects involving the preparation of technical requirements, coordination with the department, tender processes, and equipment installation require more coordination. Targeted fees increase evidence and provide transparent control of stages, while donations allow the project to be supported by operational procurement of small but critical items, shortening the overall cycle.
To strengthen the long-term sustainability of public finances, it is worth building a portfolio of military bonds. Such a tool provides a return of the face value and coupon income to the investor, and a resource for the state to make planned purchases and cover cash gaps. This is a rational choice for those who are ready to accept market fluctuations and seek to support defense systematically, at the macro level, with a predictable financial result.
The most balanced approach for individuals and businesses is often a combination. A core portfolio of military bonds forms the "backbone" of macro-financial support, while regular direct donations cover urgent needs and participation in targeted fundraising directs resources to complex, specialized projects. This strategy allows you to ensure speed, targeting, and sustainability at the same time by adjusting the proportion of instruments to current tasks and your priorities.
Practical tips: how to act today
Start by prioritizing whether you need urgency or sustainability. If you need to have a quick impact in the coming days, focus on direct donations through trusted organizations with public reporting. If you want to maintain budgetary predictability and gain financial discipline at the same time, build a core portfolio of military bonds that is aligned with your horizon and risk tolerance.
Formulate your own contribution allocation policy. For example, fix a share of regular donations for urgent needs and a share of investments in military bonds for macro-financial support, and leave a reserve for participation in targeted fundraising for specialized projects. Review the proportions monthly or quarterly, depending on the dynamics of requests and market conditions.
Check counterparties and documents. For donations, check the legal status of the recipient, details, detailed reports, and confirmation of the transfer of assistance to the units. For bonds, check brokerage fees, storage conditions, tax rules on coupons, and possible consequences of early sale. Record all transactions and keep proof of payments and reports.
Plan your liquidity and horizon. Don’t invest in bonds for amounts that may be needed suddenly to avoid selling assets at a disadvantageous price. Keep a cushion of cash for unexpected urgent needs to quickly fund critical positions. When participating in targeted initiatives, check the timeframe for implementation and the organizers’ readiness for alternative solutions if technical requirements change.
Measure the results and adjust the strategy. Evaluate the impact of contributions: delivery times, number of closed requests, compliance with technical requirements, transparency of reporting, and stability of coupon payments. Based on this data, adjust the balance between donations, bonds, and participation in targeted projects. This approach allows you to act responsibly, strengthening both the immediate defense capability and the long-term resilience of the country.
Conclusions.
There is no single correct format - each of us must choose the method of assistance that suits our own capabilities, priorities, and horizon. Some people prefer direct donations with an immediate targeted effect, others prefer military bonds with financial discipline and a contribution to budget sustainability, and others prefer targeted projects with detailed milestone control.
It is important that your contribution is conscious, transparent, and regular in a form that is convenient and understandable for you. It is a variety of formats, a combination of operational and systemic support, and trust in proven initiatives that create synergy that brings us closer to a common victory.
Every hryvnia matters, and every responsible decision strengthens the defense. Choose your way to help - and together we will definitely be able to support our army, ensuring its speed today and resilience tomorrow.
